Tautalus
Regular Member
- Messages
- 573
- Reaction score
- 1,462
- Points
- 93
- Ethnic group
- Portuguese
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- I2-M223 / I-FTB15368
- mtDNA haplogroup
- H6a1b2y
In preparation for the controversial The Odyssey, mainly due to the casting choices, here is a brief description of the events.
Before the adventures of Odysseus, there was the Trojan War, described in the Iliad. Before the events of the Iliad, Helen, wife of the Spartan king Menelaus, was taken by the Trojan prince Paris and brought to Troy. Menelaus appealed to the other Greek kings, who had previously sworn to defend Helen's marriage. Led by his brother Agamemnon, they assembled a massive expedition to recover Helen, beginning the Trojan War.
The Iliad takes place during the final year of the ten year Trojan War, but it covers only about fifty days of the conflict. Rather than telling the entire war, it focuses on the consequences of one man's anger: Achilles. The conflict begins when the Greek commander Agamemnon is forced to return his captive woman and compensates himself by taking Achilles' prize, Briseis. Enraged by the insult to his honor, Achilles withdraws from the fighting, leaving the Greek army without its greatest warrior.
With Achilles absent, the Trojans, led by Hector, drive the Greeks back to their ships. The gods frequently intervene, with different deities supporting either the Greeks or the Trojans. As the Greeks face defeat, Achilles' closest friend, Patroclus, borrows Achilles' armor and leads the Greek forces into battle. He succeeds in pushing the Trojans back but is ultimately killed by Hector.
Overwhelmed by grief and guilt, Achilles reconciles with Agamemnon and returns to the battlefield wearing magnificent new armor forged by the god Hephaestus. In a furious assault, he slaughters many Trojans before confronting and killing Hector in single combat. Consumed by rage, Achilles drags Hector's body behind his chariot, refusing to allow it a proper burial.
The epic ends not with the fall of Troy but with an act of compassion. The aged Trojan king Priam secretly enters the Greek camp, begs Achilles to return Hector's body, and reminds him of his own father. Moved by Priam's courage and shared humanity, Achilles relents. The poem concludes with Hector's funeral, emphasizing both the tragedy of war and the dignity of reconciliation.
In essence, The Iliad is not the story of the Trojan Horse or the destruction of Troy. It is a meditation on honor, rage, mortality, heroism, grief, and the human cost of war, centered on the transformation of Achilles from destructive anger to compassion.
The Odyssey tells the story of the Greek hero Odysseus and his ten year journey home after the end of the Trojan War. While other Greek leaders return quickly, Odysseus is repeatedly delayed by monsters, storms, hostile gods, and his own men's mistakes. At the same time, his wife Penelope and son Telemachus struggle to preserve their household on the island of Ithaca against a group of arrogant nobles who seek Penelope's hand in marriage and consume Odysseus' wealth.
The poem opens not with Odysseus but with Telemachus. Guided by the goddess Athena, disguised as a trusted friend, he sets out to learn whether his father is still alive. He visits former Greek kings who fought at Troy and hears stories of the war and of the difficult returns of many heroes. These travels help him mature from an uncertain youth into a capable prince.
Meanwhile, Odysseus has been held for years by the nymph Calypso on her remote island. Ordered by the gods to release him, she reluctantly allows him to build a raft. Soon afterward, the sea god Poseidon, still angry because Odysseus blinded his son, the Cyclops Polyphemus, destroys the raft in a storm. Barely surviving, Odysseus reaches the land of the Phaeacians, whose princess Nausicaa helps him. At their court, Odysseus finally reveals his identity and recounts the adventures that have kept him from home.
After leaving Troy, his fleet sacks a city but is driven off by fierce resistance. They next encounter the peaceful Lotus Eaters, whose fruit causes forgetfulness, forcing Odysseus to drag his men back to their ships. On another island they discover the cave of the giant Cyclops Polyphemus. Trapped inside, Odysseus devises a clever escape by blinding the Cyclops with a sharpened stake after telling him his name is "Nobody." The men escape hidden beneath sheep. However, Odysseus' pride leads him to reveal his real name as they sail away, allowing Polyphemus to call upon Poseidon for revenge, ensuring years of suffering.
Odysseus then receives a bag containing all the winds from the wind keeper Aeolus. His crew, believing it contains treasure, opens it while Ithaca is already in sight, releasing the winds and blowing the fleet back across the sea. Aeolus refuses further help, believing the gods oppose Odysseus.
The voyage continues with encounters against the savage Laestrygonians, whose attack destroys nearly the entire fleet, leaving only Odysseus' own ship. They next arrive at the island of the enchantress Circe, who transforms many of the crew into pigs. With divine assistance from Hermes, Odysseus resists her magic, persuades her to restore his companions, and remains on her island for a year.
Circe instructs Odysseus to visit the Underworld, where he consults the prophet Tiresias. There he speaks with the spirits of his mother, fallen comrades from Troy, and legendary heroes. Tiresias warns him not to harm the sacred cattle of the sun god Helios.
Returning to the world of the living, Odysseus successfully passes the irresistible Sirens by plugging his crew's ears with wax while having himself tied to the mast so he alone may hear their song without steering toward destruction. He must then navigate between the six-headed monster Scylla and the deadly whirlpool Charybdis. Choosing the lesser evil, he loses six men to Scylla but saves the ship.
Eventually the exhausted crew lands on the island of Helios despite warnings. When contrary winds trap them, hunger drives the men to slaughter the sacred cattle while Odysseus sleeps. Zeus punishes this sacrilege by destroying the ship with a thunderbolt. Every member of the crew dies except Odysseus, who drifts alone until reaching Calypso's island, where he remains for seven years.
After finishing his tale before the Phaeacians, they escort him safely to Ithaca with magnificent gifts. Athena disguises him as an old beggar so he can observe the situation in his palace. He first reunites secretly with the loyal swineherd Eumaeus, then with Telemachus. Father and son recognize one another and secretly plan to eliminate the suitors.
Inside the palace, Odysseus endures insults and abuse while disguised. Only his old dog, Argos, recognizes him before dying. His elderly nurse also recognizes him by a scar while washing his feet but keeps the secret. Penelope remains cautious, refusing to believe reports of her husband's return.
To delay choosing a new husband, Penelope announces an archery contest. Whoever can string Odysseus' great bow and shoot an arrow through twelve aligned axe heads will marry her. None of the suitors can even string the bow. The disguised beggar asks to try. He effortlessly strings it and completes the feat.
Odysseus immediately throws off his disguise. Together with Telemachus, Eumaeus, and a few loyal servants, he kills every suitor in a fierce battle inside the palace. The disloyal servants who aided the suitors are also punished, restoring justice and order to the kingdom.
Penelope is still cautious and tests the stranger by ordering that their marriage bed be moved. Odysseus protests that this is impossible because he himself built the bed around the trunk of a living olive tree rooted in the ground. Realizing only her true husband could know this secret, Penelope finally accepts his identity, and the couple is joyfully reunited.
In the final book, the souls of the slain suitors descend to the Underworld, where they recount their fate. Odysseus visits his aged father Laertes and reveals himself. The relatives of the dead suitors seek revenge, but Athena intervenes, bringing peace and ending the cycle of violence.
Major themes :
The epic celebrates intelligence as much as strength. Unlike the warriors of the Iliad, Odysseus survives primarily through cleverness, patience, persuasion, and adaptability rather than brute force.
Homecoming (nostos) is the poem's central concern. Odysseus' greatest desire is not wealth or glory but returning to his family and reclaiming his rightful place.
Hospitality (xenia) is presented as a sacred moral duty. Good hosts, such as the Phaeacians and Eumaeus, are rewarded, while those who violate hospitality, especially the suitors and Polyphemus, are ultimately destroyed.
The story also explores loyalty and faithfulness. Penelope, Telemachus, Eumaeus, and a handful of servants remain loyal throughout Odysseus' twenty-year absence, while disloyalty brings severe consequences.
Finally, The Odyssey examines the relationship between fate, divine intervention, and human choice. The gods influence events, but Odysseus' successes and failures often result from his own decisions, his pride prolongs his journey, while his perseverance and wisdom eventually bring him home. The epic ends not simply with revenge, but with the restoration of family, kingship, justice, and peace.
This map is one of the better modern reconstructions, especially if you accept the idea that most of Odysseus' wanderings occurred in the central and western Mediterranean. However, it is not a map of established historical fact. Many of its locations, including Ogygia, Aeaea, the Lotus-Eaters, and especially the land of the Cimmerians, are educated guesses rather than identifications supported by Homer.Before the adventures of Odysseus, there was the Trojan War, described in the Iliad. Before the events of the Iliad, Helen, wife of the Spartan king Menelaus, was taken by the Trojan prince Paris and brought to Troy. Menelaus appealed to the other Greek kings, who had previously sworn to defend Helen's marriage. Led by his brother Agamemnon, they assembled a massive expedition to recover Helen, beginning the Trojan War.
The Iliad takes place during the final year of the ten year Trojan War, but it covers only about fifty days of the conflict. Rather than telling the entire war, it focuses on the consequences of one man's anger: Achilles. The conflict begins when the Greek commander Agamemnon is forced to return his captive woman and compensates himself by taking Achilles' prize, Briseis. Enraged by the insult to his honor, Achilles withdraws from the fighting, leaving the Greek army without its greatest warrior.
With Achilles absent, the Trojans, led by Hector, drive the Greeks back to their ships. The gods frequently intervene, with different deities supporting either the Greeks or the Trojans. As the Greeks face defeat, Achilles' closest friend, Patroclus, borrows Achilles' armor and leads the Greek forces into battle. He succeeds in pushing the Trojans back but is ultimately killed by Hector.
Overwhelmed by grief and guilt, Achilles reconciles with Agamemnon and returns to the battlefield wearing magnificent new armor forged by the god Hephaestus. In a furious assault, he slaughters many Trojans before confronting and killing Hector in single combat. Consumed by rage, Achilles drags Hector's body behind his chariot, refusing to allow it a proper burial.
The epic ends not with the fall of Troy but with an act of compassion. The aged Trojan king Priam secretly enters the Greek camp, begs Achilles to return Hector's body, and reminds him of his own father. Moved by Priam's courage and shared humanity, Achilles relents. The poem concludes with Hector's funeral, emphasizing both the tragedy of war and the dignity of reconciliation.
In essence, The Iliad is not the story of the Trojan Horse or the destruction of Troy. It is a meditation on honor, rage, mortality, heroism, grief, and the human cost of war, centered on the transformation of Achilles from destructive anger to compassion.
The Odyssey tells the story of the Greek hero Odysseus and his ten year journey home after the end of the Trojan War. While other Greek leaders return quickly, Odysseus is repeatedly delayed by monsters, storms, hostile gods, and his own men's mistakes. At the same time, his wife Penelope and son Telemachus struggle to preserve their household on the island of Ithaca against a group of arrogant nobles who seek Penelope's hand in marriage and consume Odysseus' wealth.
The poem opens not with Odysseus but with Telemachus. Guided by the goddess Athena, disguised as a trusted friend, he sets out to learn whether his father is still alive. He visits former Greek kings who fought at Troy and hears stories of the war and of the difficult returns of many heroes. These travels help him mature from an uncertain youth into a capable prince.
Meanwhile, Odysseus has been held for years by the nymph Calypso on her remote island. Ordered by the gods to release him, she reluctantly allows him to build a raft. Soon afterward, the sea god Poseidon, still angry because Odysseus blinded his son, the Cyclops Polyphemus, destroys the raft in a storm. Barely surviving, Odysseus reaches the land of the Phaeacians, whose princess Nausicaa helps him. At their court, Odysseus finally reveals his identity and recounts the adventures that have kept him from home.
After leaving Troy, his fleet sacks a city but is driven off by fierce resistance. They next encounter the peaceful Lotus Eaters, whose fruit causes forgetfulness, forcing Odysseus to drag his men back to their ships. On another island they discover the cave of the giant Cyclops Polyphemus. Trapped inside, Odysseus devises a clever escape by blinding the Cyclops with a sharpened stake after telling him his name is "Nobody." The men escape hidden beneath sheep. However, Odysseus' pride leads him to reveal his real name as they sail away, allowing Polyphemus to call upon Poseidon for revenge, ensuring years of suffering.
Odysseus then receives a bag containing all the winds from the wind keeper Aeolus. His crew, believing it contains treasure, opens it while Ithaca is already in sight, releasing the winds and blowing the fleet back across the sea. Aeolus refuses further help, believing the gods oppose Odysseus.
The voyage continues with encounters against the savage Laestrygonians, whose attack destroys nearly the entire fleet, leaving only Odysseus' own ship. They next arrive at the island of the enchantress Circe, who transforms many of the crew into pigs. With divine assistance from Hermes, Odysseus resists her magic, persuades her to restore his companions, and remains on her island for a year.
Circe instructs Odysseus to visit the Underworld, where he consults the prophet Tiresias. There he speaks with the spirits of his mother, fallen comrades from Troy, and legendary heroes. Tiresias warns him not to harm the sacred cattle of the sun god Helios.
Returning to the world of the living, Odysseus successfully passes the irresistible Sirens by plugging his crew's ears with wax while having himself tied to the mast so he alone may hear their song without steering toward destruction. He must then navigate between the six-headed monster Scylla and the deadly whirlpool Charybdis. Choosing the lesser evil, he loses six men to Scylla but saves the ship.
Eventually the exhausted crew lands on the island of Helios despite warnings. When contrary winds trap them, hunger drives the men to slaughter the sacred cattle while Odysseus sleeps. Zeus punishes this sacrilege by destroying the ship with a thunderbolt. Every member of the crew dies except Odysseus, who drifts alone until reaching Calypso's island, where he remains for seven years.
After finishing his tale before the Phaeacians, they escort him safely to Ithaca with magnificent gifts. Athena disguises him as an old beggar so he can observe the situation in his palace. He first reunites secretly with the loyal swineherd Eumaeus, then with Telemachus. Father and son recognize one another and secretly plan to eliminate the suitors.
Inside the palace, Odysseus endures insults and abuse while disguised. Only his old dog, Argos, recognizes him before dying. His elderly nurse also recognizes him by a scar while washing his feet but keeps the secret. Penelope remains cautious, refusing to believe reports of her husband's return.
To delay choosing a new husband, Penelope announces an archery contest. Whoever can string Odysseus' great bow and shoot an arrow through twelve aligned axe heads will marry her. None of the suitors can even string the bow. The disguised beggar asks to try. He effortlessly strings it and completes the feat.
Odysseus immediately throws off his disguise. Together with Telemachus, Eumaeus, and a few loyal servants, he kills every suitor in a fierce battle inside the palace. The disloyal servants who aided the suitors are also punished, restoring justice and order to the kingdom.
Penelope is still cautious and tests the stranger by ordering that their marriage bed be moved. Odysseus protests that this is impossible because he himself built the bed around the trunk of a living olive tree rooted in the ground. Realizing only her true husband could know this secret, Penelope finally accepts his identity, and the couple is joyfully reunited.
In the final book, the souls of the slain suitors descend to the Underworld, where they recount their fate. Odysseus visits his aged father Laertes and reveals himself. The relatives of the dead suitors seek revenge, but Athena intervenes, bringing peace and ending the cycle of violence.
Major themes :
The epic celebrates intelligence as much as strength. Unlike the warriors of the Iliad, Odysseus survives primarily through cleverness, patience, persuasion, and adaptability rather than brute force.
Homecoming (nostos) is the poem's central concern. Odysseus' greatest desire is not wealth or glory but returning to his family and reclaiming his rightful place.
Hospitality (xenia) is presented as a sacred moral duty. Good hosts, such as the Phaeacians and Eumaeus, are rewarded, while those who violate hospitality, especially the suitors and Polyphemus, are ultimately destroyed.
The story also explores loyalty and faithfulness. Penelope, Telemachus, Eumaeus, and a handful of servants remain loyal throughout Odysseus' twenty-year absence, while disloyalty brings severe consequences.
Finally, The Odyssey examines the relationship between fate, divine intervention, and human choice. The gods influence events, but Odysseus' successes and failures often result from his own decisions, his pride prolongs his journey, while his perseverance and wisdom eventually bring him home. The epic ends not simply with revenge, but with the restoration of family, kingship, justice, and peace.
The placement of the Cimmerians in Iberia is not because Homer says they lived there, but because the map's author interprets Homer's "edge of Ocean" as the Atlantic beyond the western Mediterranean. Historically, the real Cimmerians were an Iron Age people of the Pontic steppe, and within the poem itself the Cimmerians function primarily as inhabitants of a mythic borderland at the threshold of the Underworld rather than as a geographically identifiable nation.
Chronological order of the Trojan Cycle
1. The wedding of Peleus and Thetis, where Eris throws the Golden Apple.
2. The Judgement of Paris, who awards the apple to Aphrodite.
3. Aphrodite promises Paris the most beautiful woman in the world.
4. Paris visits Sparta and takes (or elopes with) Helen.
5. Menelaus invokes the Oath of Tyndareus.
6. The Greek kings gather under Agamemnon and sail for Troy.
7. The first nine years of the Trojan War (mostly omitted from Homer).
8. The Iliad (about 50 days in the tenth year).
9. The death of Achilles (after the Iliad).
10. The Trojan Horse and the fall of Troy.
11. The Odyssey, describing Odysseus' ten-year journey home.
Chronological Order of The Odyssey
Unlike the Iliad, The Odyssey does not tell its story in chronological order. Homer begins in the tenth year of Odysseus' wanderings, then uses flashbacks to recount the earlier adventures. The chronological sequence is as follows:
1. The Fall of Troy – After the Greeks capture Troy using the Trojan Horse, Odysseus sets sail for home with twelve ships.
2. Ismarus (Land of the Cicones) – Odysseus' men sack the city but linger too long. The Cicones counterattack, and many Greeks are killed.
3. Cape Malea – A violent storm blows the fleet off course into unknown seas.
4. The Lotus-Eaters – Some crewmen eat the lotus fruit, lose all desire to return home, and must be dragged back to the ships.
5. The Cyclops Polyphemus – Odysseus blinds the Cyclops to escape his cave. As he sails away, he reveals his identity, causing Polyphemus to pray to his father, Poseidon, who curses Odysseus' voyage.
6. Aeolus, Keeper of the Winds – Aeolus gives Odysseus a bag containing the winds. His curious crew opens it when Ithaca is already in sight, and the ships are blown back across the sea.
7. The Laestrygonians – Giant cannibals destroy eleven of Odysseus' twelve ships. Only his own ship escapes.
8. Aeaea (Circe's Island) – The sorceress Circe turns many of the crew into pigs. Odysseus, protected by Hermes, forces her to restore them. They remain on the island for a year.
9. The Underworld (Land of the Cimmerians) – Following Circe's instructions, Odysseus sails to the entrance of the Underworld and consults the prophet Tiresias, who warns him about the dangers ahead.
10. Return to Circe – Odysseus returns briefly to Circe's island, where she gives him further advice for the journey.
11. The Sirens – The crew plugs their ears with wax while Odysseus, tied to the mast, hears the irresistible song without steering the ship toward destruction.
12. Scylla and Charybdis – Odysseus sails between the six-headed monster Scylla and the deadly whirlpool Charybdis. Scylla devours six of his men.
13. Thrinacia (Island of the Sun) – Despite repeated warnings, the starving crew slaughter the sacred cattle of Helios. Zeus destroys the ship with a thunderbolt. Every crewman dies except Odysseus.
14. Ogygia (Calypso's Island) – Odysseus drifts to the island of the nymph Calypso, who keeps him there for seven years, hoping he will become her husband.
15. The Gods Intervene – Athena persuades Zeus to order Calypso to release Odysseus. He builds a raft and departs.
16. Shipwreck and Scheria – Poseidon wrecks the raft, but Odysseus survives and reaches the land of the Phaeacians. Princess Nausicaa helps him, and at the royal court he recounts all of the adventures above in a long flashback.
17. Return to Ithaca – The Phaeacians carry Odysseus home while he sleeps and leave him safely on the shore of Ithaca.
18. Disguise and Reunion – Athena disguises Odysseus as an old beggar. He reunites secretly with the loyal swineherd Eumaeus and then with his son Telemachus.
19. The Palace – Odysseus enters his own palace disguised as a beggar, observing the arrogant suitors who have occupied his home and seek to marry Penelope.
20. The Contest of the Bow – Penelope announces that whoever can string Odysseus' bow and shoot an arrow through twelve axe heads will become her husband. Only Odysseus succeeds.
21. The Slaughter of the Suitors – Odysseus reveals his identity and, with Telemachus and a few loyal servants, kills all the suitors and punishes the disloyal servants.
22. Recognition by Penelope – Penelope tests Odysseus by mentioning their marriage bed. His response proves his identity, and the husband and wife are finally reunited.
23. Peace Restored – Odysseus visits his elderly father Laertes. The relatives of the slain suitors seek revenge, but Athena intervenes and establishes peace, bringing the epic to its conclusion.
Last edited: