Bodin
Regular Member
- Messages
- 503
- Reaction score
- 4
- Points
- 0
- Location
- Praia , Cape Verde
- Ethnic group
- Srbin
- Y-DNA haplogroup
- I2a1b-Din
- mtDNA haplogroup
- X2
Well you seem to understand and know realy little.South and North Ossetians are diferent - south are closser to South Caucasian nations and North Ossetian to North Caucasian nations - THAT COULD ONLY MEAN THEY MIXED HEAVILY WITH NEIGHBOURS AND THATS HOW THEY GET THEY G DNA.That has nothing to do with intermarryingBodin, I don't think you understand what tribal culture is like nor do you know what people intermarrying within a tribe means, I'm not gonna baby-step you through it, when people within the same tribe intermarry, one lineage usually comes off too high, in the case of Ossetian groups, G2a seems like that lineage, it's due to a genetic drift, if you don't understand that, it's not my problem.
Nobody cares about Serbians and Croatians in this subject, they're irrelevant, as far as I know, they speak a Slavic language and they carry Southeast European genes for most part, unless they find "Ancient DNA" for Scythians/Sarmatians carrying haplogroup I2a, you have no argument here, so stop wasting your breath on this useless argument.
Soon we'll find out, don't worry.
The C was carried among the Andronovo culture (Kurgan culture / Proto-Indo-Iranians):
View attachment 5180
I don't even understand this, the English is very bad.
What does I2a1b have to do with Medes crushing the Assyrians? This is stupid and has nothing to do with anything, well, Medes and Chaldeans crushed the Assyrians, the Persians crushed the Medes and Chaldeans, the Macedonians/Greeks crushed the Persians, etc, we can go on and on, but unless you have evidence that I2a1b existed among ancient Iranians, your arguments are useless and you have no point, and when I say evidence, I mean "Ancient DNA" studies, is there any ancient DNA of I2a1b found among ancient Iranians? If not, please stop repeating yourself.
Ofcourse Serbs and Croats are realy relevant when we speack about I2a1b haplogroup -they have most of it in whole world . I dont know what do you think we should talk about regarding I2a1b
Yes there was some C in Andronovo , but you mentioned it in conection with Scythians , and that is why I neaded to corect you
about bad English part : You said Europeans are not Aryans , and this is not truth . Aryans is term used by every IE speacker , egzamples : Vandalic tribe Hazdingi used to be called Haria ; one of Frankish tribes is RipuArians ; Roman personal name Arian ; Ossetians call themselves Iron and they languague Iraetae
Your arguing is also pointless because you dont have any ancient findings of I2a1b on Balkans , ofcourse Serbs and Croats would havea lot of southeast european autosomal DNA - that is where they live
Have you been in some diplomacy or secret service school ? You seam very skillfool in twisting the facts , and avoiding to answer the questions , I am well aware of all techniques of Black and White propaganda so it dont going to pass . What is reason you believe I2a1b is Balkanic?