@ Maleth
read this
You must know that y haplotype goes to the level of person ... if Croat in Croatia has E1b haplotype, Y haplotype will go back to a village or area in southern Albania or Serbia where his ancestors lived. How that Croat can be Croatian when all his Y relatives are in today's Albania and Kosovo and ultimately in the Greek if it turns out that E1b originally formed and has source in Greece, that haplotype has nothing to do with arrival of Croats 1,500 years ago..
In Albania, exists I2a haplotype, it is possible that certain percentage is Croatian origin. If Albanian have I2a1b2a1a3 A356, how can be Albanian origin when most of Albanian are here autochton and has nothing to do with arrival on the Balkan 1,500 years ago. He is today Albanian but its origin is Croatian ... it's logic..
there was a strong minority of Jews in Makedonia, at 1860 moved to 5th Avenue NY most, some still live here,
and I ask you could a Jew Diaspora in Greece to be E?
after 70's many Palestinians devastate at
Thessaloniki and around towns,
some are living
'next door' they might be E, should I baptise them Albanians cause they have E?
and to go more deep.
Greek language, Serb/Croat, Albanian languages are IE, meaning they are after Bronze era comers, why we connect E with IE?
were E Hg carriers IE speakers?
so search better who is the racist,
now to be honest,
I do not know what you believe about E in Balkans,
But I do not share the idea that E entered Balkans at Neolithic era, and has nothing to do with Iberian E
and I have the right, since the difference among Iberian and Balkan/minor Asia existance of E is 4000 (E of Konya), as much as from late bronze era to modern times,
besides the existance of Bottle neck, with the connection of M-78 M-81 and E-v13 and the one mutation given in Balkans (bosnia) how much possible is with an existance of 8000 years and with an existance of 4000 years with such numbers and density?????? I am not a calcutator neither a genetist, but I believe someone can help, or you understand
I believe is 4000 years old in Balkans, and create core and densities with Roman Legions, and Arab expand, (sources give christians to leave south East mediterenean due to Islam expansion)
if you knew the story of mt Athos, Christian monks until 6-7th century
lived in Sina and Egyptian Arabian Syrrian deserts) after 700 BC they devastate to Cappadokia and mt Athos and with them villages and followers,
as also the density of E in Balkans is strange and pecculiar, cause if I follow the road of E Hg carriers devastation, surely I expect different results, and not such densities and peaks,
which might be due to rate of reproduction, what I mean? search Deutshland, which might have not for example X hg, suddenly X enters antd reproduce with 2 woman (that is allowed and legal, if you make 2 marriages and a divorce) having 4-6 children with each and 50% of boys gives an average of 4-6 sons X carriers,
and the Z Hg due to religion makes one or none marriage with average of 2-3 children means reproduce with 1,5 factor per generation,
result????
and to finalize,
even if E is neolithic, why an E carrier in Bulgaria for example should be Albanian as Hrvat 22 say, and not a neolithic person who habbit there from neolithic times, and assimilated by Bulgarians?
if you do not understand the major propaganda of Albanians who run great nationalistic era, is that all E in Balkans are Albanians, so they are autochthonus pre IE, and all E in Balkans are Albanians, and they their Language is not a language of IE (R1xyz) but the mother of IE language,
away from E is not IE so is not Albanian Greek or Serbian, but a previous substractum, or a later migration, (both possible) who got assimilated by IE,
so I ask you, a Palestinian who came at 70's or earlier in Greece, and bear a son, is his son Albanian, cause he is E-V13 carrier, and lives in Balkans?
your problem is what? the word Palestinian? ok if I used word Cypriot or Maltese, would make any difference?
plz feel free to tell whatever you want, but plz read the above and bellow first,
and post again?
"
if Croat in Croatia has E1b haplotype, Y haplotype will go back to a village or area in southern Albania or Serbia where his ancestors lived."
I ask,
could that man in Croatia to be son of a Sicilian or a Cillician that followed a Roman legion? or a Roman master? or a Roman officer at his villa? or a Christian priest? even a forgoten hunted Jew? why we baptise him Albanian or Serb or Greek?