- Reaction score
- Y-DNA haplogroup
Am I also a sock puppet because I think Matzinger comes across as an idiot?
You are totally missing the point. Thraco-Illyrian/eat_tain has a tendency of creating a chain of accounts subsequently.
Don't worry, no need to have an identity crisis because E-V13 hasn't shown up yet, the most important regions haven't been tested. You can calm down instead of buying into Derites crazy speculations, I will personally contact a director to make a movie out of his fantastical ideas. Whoever is pumping out those superhero movies every year could surely make a great movie about Albanian speaking peoples in the Trojan wars.
I am not having an identity crisis. I am following reason and evidences so far. I rather think it's the opposite, it's you projecting your own fears. It's you and your buddies coming here replying on rage.
A renowned linguist as Matzinger claims that Albanian is not descended from Illyrian and this triggers us to base models. Unless someone completely rejects his decade worth of study and he admits it, then we all will claim otherwise.
But if E-V13 is not to be found among Illyrian core, and Albanian is not descended from Illyrian, then there you have it. I mean, E-V13 might be found among Illyrians, i am not betting it was not. But if we have to follow material culture then i assume it had minimal presence. Instead you have two groups the Central Balkans derived Channeled-Ware (Triballi, Dardanii, Paeoni and likely Encheleii) and Eastern-Balkans (Daco -Thracians).
Then again, unless Albanian linguistically is proven to have some connection with Armenian and Greek then we will exclude E-V13 as well, and probably R1b-Z2105 will be the sole candidate.
As for Derite, all of these ad-hominems on cycle are meaningless. I don't think he has anything against your line (his maternal line is J2b2-L283 afaik), but of course based on linguistic and genetic evidences he will make assumptions. As for the movies, a movie about Sea People clashing with Ramsess III would be awesome (Battle of Delta was more epic than Trojan War).