Politics Balkanian disagreements.

Sile said:
So tell me which albanian is taught in school............gheg or tosk ...............you must know if you know so much about the albanian language
Click to expand...

The Standart Albanian.
 
Piro Ilir said:
No, indeed you are at just an anti Albanian. Instead do you have any argument. By order of the man on the right ,who was an orthodox, was killed the Greek bishop Foti during 1908.
Click to expand...
About Cerciz Topulli and Mihal Grameno.
The movie "Mesonjetorja", at 1h24` is the moment of the killing of the greek bishop Foti.

Komitet paguajne vetem me plumba dhe kete ti e di fort mire hiresi.
The Komits pay only with bullets Eminence and you know this very well.



 
[h=1]Liri a vdekje..[/h]Liberty or death.

The moment of the killing of the Turk Bimbash and the song.

Piro Ilir said:
Sooner or later the today Greek orthodox bishop will be deported from Albania and replaced with an ethnic Albanian archbishop
Click to expand...
Do ta heqim zvarre qenin me gjithe kelyshet e tije.
 
Angela said:
Argue until you're all blue in the face. Knock yourselves out. However, calling other people liars or telling them to shut up is totally out of line in civilized debate. Keep the discussions civil and data based. This isn't mud wrestling.

Most particularly, as I already mentioned upthread, anything that could be construed as supporting or threatening ethnic cleansing or extermination will result in an immediate and permanent ban. Has everybody understood?
Click to expand...
yes agreed ethic cleansing is discrace no hear this from me.
 
ukaj said:
Standard albanian is tought now even in kosova
Click to expand...

From what I read yesterday, Standard Albanian comes from 100% Tosk and very little Gheg. in the next generation with Tosk being taught in Kosovo as you stated, the demise of Gheg is a fact.

Correct me if I am wrong, my feeling is that Tosk is more influenced by Greek words and Gheg more by slavic words ?
 
Sile said:
From what I read yesterday, Standard Albanian comes from 100% Tosk and very little Gheg. in the next generation with Tosk being taught in Kosovo as you stated, the demise of Gheg is a fact.

Correct me if I am wrong, my feeling is that Tosk is more influenced by Greek words and Gheg more by slavic words ?
Click to expand...
No not true gheg is more latin an belive it or not their is some very old greek in gheg also.But yes their is some slavnic in both dilects but from old church slav.From what i read gheg is starting to wipe out the turkish influence in their dilect an no their is much in standard but not as much as tosk around 70% is tosk.many albanians say hajdi witch means come or come hear old word is eja that many ghegs are staring to use.But sadly i am hoping it will be revived my cousin is trying to push gheg only in gheg regions,,praying so it happens.As for it being wiped out their is many albanians who refuse to speak tosk an at homes they only speak gheg,It is a hard case.In away i think it is good to speak one language but in other way if gheg is gone then so is albanian laguage as i truly belive it was the old language of our ancestors.no ofence to anyone
 
LABERIA said:
About Cerciz Topulli and Mihal Grameno.
The movie "Mesonjetorja", at 1h24` is the moment of the killing of the greek bishop Foti.

Komitet paguajne vetem me plumba dhe kete ti e di fort mire hiresi.
The Komits pay only with bullets Eminence and you know this very well.



Click to expand...
Oh, I love this moment. Both actors are too good. That scene is amazing. Indeed that's not just a fiction, but it's a true story. It really happened.
I wander when they are gonna expels from Albania the Greek archbishop. He is really anti Albanian
 
LABERIA said:
[h=1]Liri a vdekje..[/h]Liberty or death.

The moment of the killing of the Turk Bimbash and the song.


Do ta heqim zvarre qenin me gjithe kelyshet e tije.
Click to expand...
Many moments from these movies happened. We can see there truly the Turks and Greeks collaborating together against Albanians
 
Sile said:
From what I read yesterday, Standard Albanian comes from 100% Tosk and very little Gheg. in the next generation with Tosk being taught in Kosovo as you stated, the demise of Gheg is a fact.

Correct me if I am wrong, my feeling is that Tosk is more influenced by Greek words and Gheg more by slavic words ?
Click to expand...
No, partly tosk is influenced by the Greek accent, not by words. Albanian standard language is based mostly in tosk dialect. It has either gheg dialect within.
 
ukaj said:
No not true gheg is more latin an belive it or not their is some very old greek in gheg also.But yes their is some slavnic in both dilects but from old church slav.From what i read gheg is starting to wipe out the turkish influence in their dilect an no their is much in standard but not as much as tosk around 70% is tosk.many albanians say hajdi witch means come or come hear old word is eja that many ghegs are staring to use.But sadly i am hoping it will be revived my cousin is trying to push gheg only in gheg regions,,praying so it happens.As for it being wiped out their is many albanians who refuse to speak tosk an at homes they only speak gheg,It is a hard case.In away i think it is good to speak one language but in other way if gheg is gone then so is albanian laguage as i truly belive it was the old language of our ancestors.no ofence to anyone
Click to expand...
Gheg can't be gone. It survived the Slavic invasion. Sooner or later the official language will change. Don't forget the largest metropolitan city of Albanians, Tirana speaks gheg, even after a long period of tosk administration. Gheg survived 6-7 centuries of Roman invasion and other 4-5 centuries of Slavic invasion. There will be always ghegs.
 
Ike said:
This is why I am not communicating with you anymore. You lack basic logic. You have the answer for this question already.
Click to expand...
If you don't communicate with me ,I am not losing anything, besides your epithets against me like, liar, terrorist, deceptive etc. And don't forget sir, come back when you find some reliable arguments.
 
Piro Ilir said:
If you don't communicate with me ,I am not losing anything, besides your epithets against me like, liar, terrorist, deceptive etc. And don't forget sir, come back when you find some reliable arguments.
Click to expand...

No, that was you mission, but you clearly don't remember...
 
Piro Ilir said:
Gheg can't be gone. It survived the Slavic invasion. Sooner or later the official language will change. Don't forget the largest metropolitan city of Albanians, Tirana speaks gheg, even after a long period of tosk administration. Gheg survived 6-7 centuries of Roman invasion and other 4-5 centuries of Slavic invasion. There will be always ghegs.
Click to expand...
very true an i hope so
 
ukaj said:
very true an i hope so
Click to expand...

once these Gheg children learn Tosk in schools , the demise of Gheg will speed up ......maybe in one generation.

Pity.............another language to go in the world..............one day only English will rule:grin:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

This thread has been viewed 455338 times.

Back
Top