No R1a in Bronze Age India, Iran, Anatolia, Greece & Italy, who were Indo-Europeans?!

[IndicMan]

Lol why are you referring to Swat Culture again and again?
They are NOT the Rig Vedic People!

Rig Vedic People are much more likely to have entered Indian Subcontinent through Pirak.

 

[Philjames100]

What is your source?

I gave you the source. Narasimhan et al 2019 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6822619/

Supplementary material, Table S1-S5

Why are you using the preprint from 2018 when the full paper and data was published in 2019?

 

[Shahmiri]

Lol why are you referring to Swat Culture again and again?
They are NOT the Rig Vedic People!

Rig Vedic People are much more likely to have entered Indian Subcontinent through Pirak.

So you believe Vedic People came from the west (Balochistan), not the north? I agree.

 

[IndicMan]

Of course they came from the west but they originated in the North.

 

[Philjames100]

Germany:

Degenau dolmen

Actually, samples from related dolmens in southern Germany/northern Switzerland/eastern France (published in Furtwangler 2020) all belong to G2a2, except for one R1b-L151:

Furtwangler et al. 2020

https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolmen_vom_Typ_Schwörstadt

 

[Philjames100]

So is G2a the link between these megalithic dolmens in Europe and India?

link

Germany:

Degenau dolmen

India:

 

[Philjames100]

North Caucasus dolmen:

Dolmen in India (Deccan):

North Caucasus dolmens map:

Trifonov 2014

 

[kingjohn]

While it is very likely r1a-z93 is realy indo-iranian
Aka aryan Marker i want to see it in mitanni and median ancient remains for people here to back
Up there claims...

P.s
Dont be surprised to find r1b instead of r1a-z93

 

[Shahmiri]

Of course they came from the west but they originated in the North.

Do you believe this one:

 

[MOESAN]

WSH is not West Siberian Hunter Gatherers,but WESTERN STEPPE HERDERS!

OK, THanks! I was far in West!

 

[MOESAN]

WSH is not West Siberian Hunter Gatherers,but WESTERN STEPPE HERDERS!

OK it changes the game a bit! I was rovering in nowhereland.

 

[IndicMan]

Not at all!
You are using an outdated map.

 

[kingjohn]

fatyanovo carried r-z93

https://eurogenes.blogspot.com/2020/07/fatyanovo-males-were-rich-in-y.html

p.s
he has an agenda but facts on in his side
but as i said in my previews post
i want to see the r-z93 remains in mittani and median and
than it would be the last nail in the coffin ..

 

[Shahmiri]

While it is very likely r1a-z93 is realy indo-iranianAka aryan Marker i want to see it in mitanni and median ancient remains for people here to backUp there claims...P.sDont be surprised to find r1b instead of r1a-z93

As you see no ancient R1a-Z93 has been found in South Asia where it has already a high frequency, those ones are R1a1a1 and R1a1a1b, it seems to be clear it will never be found in the west of Iran where R1a has a very low frequency.

 

[kingjohn]

As you see no ancient R1a-Z93 has been found in South Asia where it has already a high frequency, those ones are R1a1a1 and R1a1a1b, it seems to be clear it will never be found in the west of Iran where R1a has a very low frequency.

so what do you think
will be the ancient mittani and median remains
j2, g, r1b ?

 

[Shahmiri]

so what do you think
will be the ancient mittani and median remains
j2, g, r1b ?

Of course J2, not only in Iran but also Bronze Age India, Anatolia, Greece and Italy.

 

[Philjames100]

As you see no ancient R1a-Z93 has been found in South Asia

Why do you lie so blatantly? Do you think no one notices?

 

[Anfänger]

Why do you lie so blatantly? Do you think no one notices?

Just ignore him... don't feed the troll.

 

[Shahmiri]

Why do you lie so blatantly? Do you think no one notices?

You yourself said those ancient ones are R1a1a1 and R1a1a1b, not R1a1a1b2 (Z93).

 

[Shahmiri]

Just ignore him... don't feed the troll.

Please stay out of this thread, if you have nothing to say except trolling.