- Reaction score
- Katerini Pieria Makedonia
- Ethnic group
I was laughing when i read this post of yours. You say Ottomans originated and come from Persia and Azerbaijan, and basing upon this argument you say that the Ottomans are of Middle East Caucasian origin. Very funny, do you know where the Ottomans came from before the settlements in Iran, Azerbaijan and Syria areas? Let me answer, first of all Ottomans are not another nation, or do not represent the name of a nation, rather Osman is a name of a Turk family leader in the 13th-14.th century. The Ottomans are of the Karakeçili-Kayı Tribe of Oghuz Turks. The Oghuz Turks all have settled in Anatolia, Iran and Azerbaijan areas during the 11th-13th century(with the Selcuk Empire), and came from Central Asia-Turkmenistan area. After the battle of Malazgirt, where the Selcuks(another Oghuz family Tribe who rules a Turk Empire) have beaten the Byzantins, all Byzantins have left Anatolia. And also an important part of the Byzantin armies were of Kuman Kıpchak Turk origin.
And it is also a proven fact by many historians that Turks have been in Anatolia thousands of years before the Oghuz Turks.
So Selcuks did not come directly from Mongolia, but they have migrated from Turkmenistan to all countries between Turkmenistan and Turkiye. But, since the Selcuks are of the Oghuz Tribe, and since the Turk nation has three main tribes, namely Oghuz, Karluk and Kipchak, this means that Selcuks and Ottomans are both descendants of Asian Huns(Xiongnu Turks). So they actually do come from Mongolia, but not in 11th century but during the first centuries.
it is funny, but only in areas where seljuk settled we found white desert (Zinyang) Y-Dna, cause I in Turkey it is connected with Curds and Dinaric, Serbians Croats Romanians, And proves that settlement 1000 years BC,
J is ancient Here, in fact many J-Ydna are considered Greek,
The linguistic proves that Turks mainly ottomans were in Touch with Greeks before 11 Century AD, so infact almost 35% of urkey pop is cinsidered Turkish and that is under discuss, cause many believe that only 10-15% is Turkish, and mostly are converted,
the Numerous of 300 000 Seljuk and 80 000 Ottomans that were estimated at 10-11 century AD are proving that, by many Turks I have discuss Ottomans could be Alans, and not Turks,
in fact in a small search of my own, I found many common root words exept the above is also Tirmik where in Cappadokia and Pontus is Turmach, is simmilar to Greek-Byzantine Terra-machion->ter-mach->tirmich
since from mother i am Rum, i know that is enough Greek words in Turkish and they are not moggolian, so probably Ottomans had part of PIE language, or in Fact majority of Turks are not from white desert but converted minor Asians
in fact Byzantines left only from Cillikia, until today live in Turkey,
the last not converted Byzantines left in 1923 and not in 13 century,
so don't make me laugh,
the only Turkish if it is Y-Dna in Turkey is R1a
and by what I heard Ottomans were more Alans G-Ydna than R1a, there is a story that seljuk moved from east, and Ottomans from North,