Are South Slavs more Balkan Native than Slavic?

Fatherland said:
Kosovo Albanians have no Slavic DNA. You can find more North-Eastern shifted Albanians among Tosks.
Kosovar Albanians and other Ghegs shift North-West.
Click to expand...
You do realise that being Slavic is a language not just genetics this is the point of the thread actually.

How about answering my question about haplogroups?
 
Lenab said:
Megalithic and Neolithic culture is still very much in Balkans. You can't differentiate on Indo European people/sub races.

If only you saw what the last Bosnian man sent to me...
Click to expand...
Bosniak Indiana Jones

maxresdefault.jpg
 
Lenab said:
If you attack and insult me personally I will report you.

They are Romance Slavic mixed I have said that in past posts how about actually get back on topic and answering to the point of this thread? Are South Slavs actually Slavic or just pre historic Balkans
Click to expand...

Illyrian isn't Romance or Slavic, though by the time of the arrival of the Slavs Illyrians were probably largely Romanized.

South Slavs are mostly Slavic on the paternal side, with significant female-biased Balkanic admixture.
 
markod said:
Illyrian isn't Romance or Slavic, though by the time of the arrival of the Slavs Illyrians were probably largely Romanized.

South Slavs are mostly Slavic on the paternal side, with significant female-biased Balkanic admixture.
Click to expand...
Either that or they intermixed or intermarried depends which ethnic group is older
 
hrvat22 said:
By original personal names Croats are not Slavs so there is nothing from that, you have genetics and prove this migration from southern Italy to Iiiyria
Click to expand...

It would have been the other way around, a migration from the northern Balkans to Italy.
 
Lenab said:
That's my personal information.
Click to expand...
You clearly mentioned another person's name on this forum. Not acceptable.

How do you know he approves of having his name spread in random forums?

I have reported you.
 
markod said:
It would have been the other way around, a migration from the northern Balkans to Italy.
Click to expand...
And it also shares cognates with Albanian.
 
markod said:
Messapian seems to be very closely related to Albanian according to Matzinger. But Messapian isn't descended from Illyrian.
Click to expand...

What you are actually proving? For now you have not provided any genetic data to prove anything. So start using genetics otherwise you talk fairy tales.
 
hrvat22 said:
What you are actually proving? For now you have not provided any genetic data to prove anything. So start using genetics otherwise you talk fairy tales.
Click to expand...
Concrete genetic proof does not matter to the poster you are replying to.
 
Fatherland said:
You clearly mentioned another person's name on this forum. Not acceptable.

How do you know he approves of having his name spread in random forums?

I have reported you.
Click to expand...
Didn't mention the full name of the person didn't mention his or her names of the conversation didn't mention forum of the conversation it has been deleted.

I reported you for insulting me personally and pretending you didn't know the question.
 
markod said:
It would have been the other way around, a migration from the northern Balkans to Italy.
Click to expand...
Yes that's correct.

A lot of the Slavic migration to the Balkans came during the Middle Ages not all of it though most Slavic migrations are pre historic
 
Lenab said:
Didn't mention the full name of the person didn't mention his or her names of the conversation didn't mention forum of the conversation it has been deleted.

I reported you for insulting me personally and pretending you didn't know the question.
Click to expand...
I debunked your haplogroup question, you avoided my question several times about the 3 main Albanian haplogroups, ancestral to the Balkans.

Now stop replying to me, this is not a dating site. I'm already taken and you are not attractive.
 
markod said:
It would have been the other way around, a migration from the northern Balkans to Italy.
Click to expand...

The language has been preserved in about 300 inscriptions dating from the 6th to the 1st century BC.
Click to expand...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messapian_language

Illyria appears in Greco-Roman historiography from the 4th century BC
Click to expand...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illyrians#History

This means that Illyrians from the time of 4th century BC moved to southern Italy in 6th century BC.

Most probably Illyrians had time machine for time traveling.
 
Fatherland said:
I debunked your haplogroup question, you avoided my question several times about the 3 main Albanian haplogroups, ancestral to the Balkans.

Now stop replying to me, this is not a dating site. I'm already taken and you are not attractive.
Click to expand...
I didn't debunk any of your haplogroups questions there is no such thing as a Albanian haplogroup it's haplogroups that Albanians carry.

I am more attractive than you neither am I interested in Albanian men.

You can't even make out how I look in the picture i have.
 
Lenab said:
I didn't debunk any of your haplogroups questions there is no such thing as a Albanian haplogroup it's haplogroups that Albanians carry.

I am more attractive than you neither am I interested in Albanian men.

You can't even make out how I look in the picture i have.
Click to expand...
You are just very awkward in a creepy way and miles away from what is considered attractive. Nor are you feminine, perhaps that is what explains the presence of yDNA in your profile.

Take my advice and quit replying.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

This thread has been viewed 254481 times.

Back
Top